A well-planned buy-sell agreement can help protect a business when an owner dies, retires, or leaves the company. But the agreement must address more than who will buy the ownership interest—it should also consider valuation, funding, life insurance, and potential estate and gift tax consequences.
ACTEC Fellows Todd Angkatavanich and Kevin Matz discuss common types of buy-sell agreements, ways to fund a business buyout, and important tax considerations under Sections 2703 and 2036 of the Internal Revenue Code. They also examine the Supreme Court’s Connelly decision and explain why business owners should periodically review their agreements as business values and circumstances change.


Resources
Previous Estate Planning Essentials
Estate Planning for Business Owners— Explore estate planning resources for business owners, including strategies for succession planning, trusts, gifting, asset protection, and transferring business wealth to the next generation.
Need a probate or estate planning attorney? Visit ACTEC’s Find a Fellow and search by your state!
Transcript
Kevin Matz: Hello, everyone, this is ACTEC Fellow Kevin Matz of New York City, and joining me today is ACTEC Fellow Todd Angkatavanich, also of New York City.
Today we will be discussing Buy-Sell Agreements for Business Owners: Estate Planning, Funding, and Tax Considerations. So, a buy-sell agreement can be a very important part of estate and succession planning for business owners, helping determine what happens to a business owner’s interest when the owner dies, retires, or leaves a company. The agreement can be structured as a separate standalone agreement that’s devoted solely to business succession planning, but doesn’t have to. It can also be folded into a shareholder’s agreement, a partnership agreement, or a limited liability company—or LLC—operating agreement, as the case may be.
What Forms Can a Buy-Sell Agreement Take?
Now, a buy-sell agreement can take a variety of different forms. One form is a redemption agreement, where the entity buys back or redeems the ownership interest from the owner who has died, retired, or otherwise left the company. Alternatively, it could take the form of a cross-purchase agreement, in which the other owners of the company—or potentially a separate LLC owned by the other interest owners—can buy out the interest of the owner who has died, retired, or otherwise left the company. Even further, it could also be a hybrid between the two.
Now, having a buy-sell agreement is extremely important to prevent, for lack of a better word, potential chaos that could harm the continuity of the company if the business owner dies and, for example, the business interest is inherited under a deceased owner’s will by someone who has no interest whatsoever in continuing the business. It can also, through a right of first refusal, prevent ownership interest in the business from falling into potential hostile hands. It could also preserve tax benefits, such as S-Corporation status, by again—through the right of first refusal.
Now, in addition to that, you always have to say, well, what’s the purchase price going to be? How are you going to determine it? Is it going to be determined based upon an agreed value? Is it going to be based upon a formula? Is it going to be based upon an appraisal? Very importantly, you have to always manage the tax risks that are presented under Section 2703 of the Internal Revenue Code, which could cause the IRS to say, “We don’t care what value you’ve agreed upon among yourselves. We’re going to value it potentially a lot higher based on fair market value.” This could result in the purchase price being essentially only a small fraction of what the IRS says it is. And that delta is essentially a phantom asset, which could produce very adverse estate tax consequences. Todd Angkatavanich will be addressing this further later in our presentation.
How Is the Purchase Price Determined?
A very important question: How do you finance the buy-sell agreement? When the time comes to purchase the company, it can be upon death, retirement, or perhaps a sale or other transfer of the interest. Well, one approach to transfer it is to pay–basically buy it over time, pay for it with a promissory note over several years with interest on it. But what could go wrong there? What could go wrong is that—what if the business were to default? What if there were to be a default on that, in which case a promissory note may not be worth the paper it’s written on?
Well, as a result, especially where death is a triggering event, life insurance is often the funding source of choice. That in turn raises a further question: Who’s going to pay the insurance premiums? Is it going to be the company? Is it going to be the business owners? Perhaps via a gift to an irrevocable life insurance trust or maybe a separate entity such as an LLC that in turn receives capital contributions for this purpose from its partners or members?
There are many flavors to this—no right or wrong. Now, one such flavor that could be very helpful is a so-called split-dollar life insurance arrangement in which the company or donor funds the payments under an agreement which provides that upon the insured’s death or the earlier termination of the policy before death, the company will receive back the greater of the life insurance premiums paid or the cash value of the life insurance policy. Now, in that case, the amount of the taxable transfer or gift each year can be reduced potentially very significantly to the value of the economic benefit conferred by the insurance policy, which could be measured potentially based on the lower of the IRS table amount or the insurance company’s alternative term rates.
Todd, I wonder if you’d talk more about some of the tax risks that are presented here.
What Are the Key Tax Issues for Buy-Sell Agreements?
Todd Angkatavanich: Sure. Thanks, Kevin. I think just a couple comments going back to the funding, too. And you had mentioned that a lot of times you might be able to obtain life insurance that would be available on each of the different partners’ or stockholders’ lives to be available to fund the buyout at the death of one of them.
And I think it’s very important that that be sort of reviewed from time to time to make sure that there is going to be a proper funding mechanism in place because I think that there’s often sort of a dynamic where people enter into a buy-sell agreement, maybe they get the life insurance in place to fund the buyout, and then they put it in the drawer and they go on with their lives of running their businesses, right? And they don’t revisit this. And so, you know, I think it’s really important that they be revisited at least every few years, right? Because you could have the most perfectly crafted buy-sell agreement today that works perfectly, but through a combination of the passage of time and changes of values and perhaps changes of circumstances, the most perfectly crafted and funded buy-sell agreement today could end up being a disaster in five years.
How Can a Buy-Sell Agreement Be Funded?
And the funding mechanism is certainly one of those, right? You might have people that enter into an agreement when they first launched the business and they say, okay, well, we’ll get $5 million of coverage on each of our lives. And then 10 years go by and the business is now worth $50 million. And there’s a mandatory buyout in place. But there’s only $5 million of that initial insurance coverage in place. So, I think it is very important to look at these things as things that have to breathe and evolve. And the most perfectly crafted agreement today might not be appropriate in five or 10 years.
Why Should Buy-Sell Agreements and Life Insurance Be Reviewed Regularly?
Now, valuation issues, you hinted at before—very important, right? In a perfect world, our buyout price is going to be what’s going to set the value for estate tax purposes, right? And hopefully that would be the case. And in most cases involving non-family members, that will be the case. There are some exceptions, but usually that’s going to be the case. However, when we are dealing with a buy-sell agreement when you have family members involved, we need to be very mindful of IRC Section 2703, which can really frustrate things.
Basically, the tax code provision came into place in 1990, but it was really a codification of about 20 years of pre-2703 case law there before. And what it is, is what we’ll refer to as an ignoring or disregarding provision. This Section 2703 applies both for gift tax and for estate tax purposes. And it basically says, look, if you have a buy-sell agreement or other kinds of arrangements, the tax code is going to start by ignoring the value or the price set in that agreement. unless the taxpayer or the taxpayer’s estate can overcome a three-part burden of proof that:
- It’s basically entered into for legitimate business reasons,
- that it’s really not a device to transfer value to your family members for less than full consideration,
- and three, that it is really an agreement that is comparable to the type of transactions that unrelated parties would enter into.
Now, it’s easy to say, okay, well, those are only three things–rattled them off. Each of those three requirements are very difficult to satisfy, and you have to satisfy all three of them. Indeed, there’s probably 40+ years of case law under Section 2703—and before that—that go into all of this. And so, if you fail to sort of meet the requirements of Section 2703, you could have the uncomfortable situation where you have a legally enforceable contractual buyout price under the buy-sell arrangement, maybe at 1x. But Section 2703 could ignore that to establish the estate tax value, and the IRS may say it’s worth 10x. Right?
And what could happen there? Well, you could have all sorts of mismatch problems. The analogy is almost like throwing rocks into a whirlpool where you have this swirling kind of whirlpool and then you have ripple effects on top of it. But in the worst-case scenario, you could end up where the estate is legally obligated to sell that interest at 1x. But the estate tax is imposed at 10x. And so, the estate owes tax 40% of 10x, but only is actually legally receiving 1x in the door. So it may not even have enough money to cover the estate tax liability attributable to the valuation of the company under Section 2703.
Now, to add insult to injury, right, intuitively, you might say, ”Okay, but Mom and Dad are both living. If the value is higher, that’s not great, but, you know, surviving spouse is still there, and shouldn’t we defer all estate taxes until both spouses are gone because they’re both U.S. citizens?” That’s kind of a reasonable gut response. But unfortunately, the cases don’t say that. And so you could have yourself in a situation where it becomes sort of a vicious circle because you could have a first-death estate tax, even though you have a surviving spouse. And then you can result in having this kind of circular estate tax on tax on tax, where every dollar of additional tax that you pay to the IRS triggers its own estate tax.
So, it’s very important that you revisit your buy-sell agreement from time to time in order to make sure that these things are properly coordinated, because the consequences can be quite dramatic if not. Kevin, back to you.
How Does IRC Section 2703 Affect Buy-Sell Agreements?
Kevin Matz: Yeah. So, one example of where Section 2703 applied and produced a very unhappy result was actually a case decided recently by the United States Supreme Court—the Connelly case—and that was decided in favor of the government. And the issue there concerned the estate tax treatment of life insurance proceeds that are used to fund the corporate redemption obligation under a buy-sell agreement. The specific question there was whether, to determine the fair market value of the corporate shares, there should be any offset to take into account the redemption obligation to the decedent’s estate under the buy-sell agreement. The Supreme Court said ”No, there should not be any offset,” and in so doing it resolved a dispute between the various circuit courts of appeals.
Now, from a tax planning standpoint, Connelly highlights the relative estate tax benefits that can be derived from instead using not a corporate redemption agreement, but rather a cross-purchase agreement between the shareholders or partners to avoid the potential estate tax inefficiency of a corporate redemption agreement. Now, again, in order for a cross-purchase agreement to work where life insurance is involved, the life insurance policies would generally have to be payable to the surviving shareholders or to a trust or entity that would be structured for the benefit of the surviving shareholders instead of to the corporation, which was the case in Connelly. Now that is not necessarily easy. There could be some complexity there in its own right, including with respect to financing the premium payments and also getting insurance policies on each of the owners owned by the other owners. You could simplify that potentially by using a life insurance LLC—that could provide some simplification there—and also perhaps coupling it with a split-dollar life insurance agreement. Back to you, Todd.
What Does the Connelly Decision Mean for Buy-Sell Agreements?
Todd Angkatavanich: Thanks, Kevin. I think when we’re talking about buy-sell agreements—and let’s say it’s with an operating company—we also need to account for what has the stockholder or the partner done with shares during their life, right? And so what I mean by this, let’s say now you and I, Kevin, were unrelated partners in a company, right? But maybe during my lifetime, I’ve decided to make some transfers by way of gift or sale, maybe to my kids or a trust for their benefit. Maybe you’ve done the same. It’s important that be sort of considered and coordinated as part of the overall buy-sell agreement.
Now, what’s going to happen at my passing? What do we want to happen, right? Kevin, do you want to be in business with my kids or my estate? So, should there be a full buyout of my interests? Should that also include the interests that have gone into a trust for my kids? What’s the buyout price for that, right?
There’s no right or wrong answer to this, but I think it’s going to be a very bespoke thing. I think one of the benefits of buy-sell agreements too is presumably when you’re entering into that buy-sell agreement, right, you are entering into it at a time when, Kevin, you don’t—I don’t know if you’re going to be the one whose estate is being bought out or if my estate is going to be bought out. And because of that, we don’t know which side of the equation we are going to be on and so I think that infuses some inherent sort of third-party negotiation into it and inherent fairness into the negotiations.
How Should Lifetime Transfers of Business Interests Be Addressed?
The other thing is from an estate tax standpoint, whenever we’re talking about transfers during lifetime, we need to be cognizant of Section 2036 of the Internal Revenue Code, right? The so-called “pull-back” provision that can pull otherwise transferred assets back into your estate for estate tax valuation purposes if the person has held onto too much control. And so, while the bulk of the cases on this have been in the so-called investment FLP context, right, rather than an operating business, nonetheless, there are still implications that need to be considered when you’re doing a gifting or transfer program with closely held business interests. And it needs to be thought of sort of overall as part of the overall plan.
Kevin Matz: Okay. Well, thanks, Todd. I think that is essentially a wrap of what we wanted to present to you folks today. Please visit actec.org/estate-planning for more information on this and also related topics. Have a great day. Thank you.
Featured Video
Estate Planning Considerations for Small Business Owners
Small business owners need to plan for their company's transition in their estate plan. Understand the impact of state laws, beneficiaries, estate taxes and more.
ACTEC Estate Planning Essentials

ACTEC Fellows provide answers to frequently asked trust and estate planning questions in this video series.

